Drench passport on the way?

As the drench resistance train continues at speed through the New Zealand sheep industry it is leaving many lamb purchasers asking ‘why can’t drench resistance be included on the Animal Status Declaration (ASD)?’ Words Ginny Dodunski.

In Livestock7 Minutes

As the drench resistance train continues at speed through the New Zealand sheep industry it is leaving many lamb purchasers asking ‘why can’t drench resistance be included on the Animal Status Declaration (ASD)?’

There are many good reasons why this will never happen, which could be the subject of another whole article. But the good news is that Wormwise is working on a declaration that sellers of stock and land can use to report the results of onfarm drench testing, as a guide for would-be purchasers.

I say ‘a guide’ because any drench testing results, be they from a full faecal egg count reduction test, or from one or more ‘drench checks’ done on farm, can only ever be a guide. The variability in results from the tests we have available is wide – here’s an example:

You could perform a reduction test on the same triple drench on three groups of 10 lambs, from the same mob, on the same farm, and get results of 74%, 88% and 92% reduction in egg count. The numbers look very different – you’d likely be quite worried about the 74% and maybe less worried about the 92%? But the reality is that this level of variation is the norm, and that in all three cases, the drench is not performing as it should.

Results can often get ‘worse’ as the season progresses – the reason for this is the build-up of resistant worms that occur month by month in lambs under a regular drenching regime from weaning. A reduction test performed in January may look very much better than a reduction test repeated in April on the same farm.

For these reasons, and many others, vets and others have tended to stay away from ‘certifying’ the drench resistance status of farms. That said, you should be able to ask a vendor or agent to see the latest set of drench testing information from a farm. However, many farms are not able to supply this information.

In response to demand, Wormwise is developing a standardised declaration (not certificate or guarantee) for the reporting of drench testing information from farms. This is a complex area. Drench resistance needs to be reported at the worm genus level (e.g. Moxidectin was 65% effective against Teladorsagia), and sufficient detail about how the test was conducted needs to be included, so that someone reading it can assess the level of confidence that they might place on the results.

Given that interpretation of drench testing results is not a straightforward area, I’d quote my mate and fellow Wormwise facilitator, Garth Riddle, from Northland: “I personally had little understanding over the documentation of LIMS, building reports etc when purchasing my first house, so I got advice from people who did.”

The same philosophy should definitely be applied to any information you’ve been given about drench efficacy – ask to see the details, and get help from someone who really understands the subject.

Any declaration will need to be simple enough to clearly highlight the key results, but include enough background for readers to assess the quality of the information. It can make no guarantee, but is much better than flying blind.

For vendors with minimal drench resistance, a standard declaration will provide a golden opportunity to sell at a premium. For those who know they have combination resistance, perhaps it’s an opportunity double check Zolvix and Startect – at least if these are highly effective over repeat tests, the purchaser can have extra confidence that their quarantine protocol will be sound.

  • Ginny Dodunski is the B+LNZ Wormwise Programme Manager.

Farmer in favour of passport

Words Rebecca Greaves

Rangitikei farmer Roger Dalrymple says we need a whole industry approach to tackling drench resistance, and he is willing to pay a premium for animals that come with worms that are not drench resistant. Dalrymple farms south of Bulls and finishes 25,000-35,000 lambs annually, after their cropping programme. “We are quite lucky because we have a cropping rotation. We are definitely set up to deal with worm resistance.”

He says the days of solely being a lamb finisher are over, it’s all about the farm system now. “We do minimal summer lamb finishing because of the challenge with worms. It gives our soils a break, and then we have the cropping. We are quarantine drenching everything with Startect or Zolvix on entry. If we do get tempted to do summer lamb finishing, they go on to a brassica crop.”

They have introduced breeding ewes as refugia, to graze around the farm when the lamb finishing happens. Breeding cows have also been added back into the farm system to help clean up pastures and suck up worms.

Dalrymple believes we cannot tackle drench resistance as individual farms; we need a united sheep industry approach. He says farmers must be aware of their drench status, and the management tools to combat it. “I’m in favour of a passport or system where, as a finisher, we can pay for animals that provide refugia, or that can help us control worms. I’m prepared to pay a premium for someone who is doing the job correctly, for animals that come in with worms that are not drench resistant.

“For farmers, it’s about being aware of what your ability is to kill which worm, with which drenches. The important thing is that people are aware of their worm situation.”

Read More